Independent restaurant reviews

By JPR | Published: April 9, 2008

Welcome to Rossouw’s Restaurants web, the place for independent commentary on the South African restaurant scene. This website complements the printed Rossouw’s Restaurants guide, now in its seventh year. For both the printed guide and all reviews here, the principle is: reviews are conducted anonymously; and all meals are paid for. Naturally, you may not agree with all the views. You are welcome to comment on any blog. Simply follow the link below the entry. You are also welcome to send written reviews by clicking on the button on the right. Please note that not all restaurants that are reviewed in the printed guide appear on this site – nor are all on this site in the annual printed guide (which is a selection).

Posted in Posts | Tagged Add new tag, Cape, Gauteng, restaurants, South Africa | Comments closed

Genki Sushi, Stellenbosch

By JPR | Published: February 8, 2010

A restaurant that really deserves to be my recent sushi roundup is Genki Sushi in Stellenbosch, but I didn’t get there before the deadline for the story (in February’s Wine magazine). The other day I popped in for lunch and am now happy to report that Stellenbosch has one of the Cape’s better sushi spots.

It’s a small place, hole-in-the-wall interior and seats that range out onto the lovely inner town square it’s on. Inside the sushi counter dominates, where owner Arata is very hands-on, working alongside his other chefs. His sushi sidekick also has his name emblazoned on his tunic – “Handsome” it says. The floor is a ruddy wood, the tables are black, and the ceiling is covered in white paper lights for a distinctly Oriental ambience (Handsome notwithstanding!). It’s less a restaurant than a sushi bar for quick meals.

The menu is supplemented by a blackboard, and kicks off with “Japanese tapas”, items like: tako sunomono (boiled octopus salad with wakame and cucumber – delicious); yellowtail sashimi with jalapeno (as at Nobu); yakitori; crispy bang-bang prawn; and “kudu-shi”, which I also tried – thin cooked kudu meat on sushi rice, very good indeed. The rest of the menu is dead-ahead hand-rolls, sashimi and sushi in a la carte or platters, and the quality is high. Rice is tender yet firm, the fish very well prepared. It’s also refreshing to see some “alternative” ideas to the tuna and salmon maki standards.

Wine list is small and short, but workable, and the service is willing and friendly. So if you’re in the area, do take a look.

Mon-Sat lunch and dinner. De Wet Centre, cnr of Bird and Church Streets, Stellenbosch. 021 887 5699

Posted in Restaurants Cape | Leave a comment

The Real Beef

By JPR | Published: February 3, 2010

One of the great marketing coups of late is to sell the consumer the notion that the term “corn-fed” when it applies to beef means better beef. “Corn/grain fed” is used as a stamp of quality on many menus. But if you stop to consider, you’ll recall that cattle are naturally grass-eaters. So what makes a steak better that comes from an animal that’s eaten a diet it’s not supposed to eat?

The answer lies in commerce. … continue reading

Posted in Food talk | 3 Comments

River Café, Constantia refreshed

By JPR | Published: February 1, 2010

Constantia Uitsig’s River Café has had a shake-up of late – and it’s a promising one. As a south peninsula favourite, it has a strong pedigree, but in the last while it has slid into a groove of ordinariness that exposed the menu prices. Yet, it’s lovely bucolic setting and garden spaces continued to draw the punters, many of a mature mien as the place has always had something of a tea house character to it. Now Luke Dale-Roberts of sister restaurant La Colombe has taken charge and UK-experienced chef Scot is leading the renaissance with his signature fish pie and pecan tart.

It’s a small one page menu printed on A4 paper to change as often as required. Interesting ideas sit alongside tried and tested dishes – so a fresh apricot, feta and rocket salad with walnut dressing as a starter joins niçoise and Caesar salads; while for mains a fillet with Bearnaise, rosemary fries and a cauliflower and Gorgonzola gratin shares space with a dish consisting of grilled asparagus and porcini mushrooms, poached duck egg, artichoke cream, bacon and parsley dressing.

The Caesar salad was as close to textbook as SA gets, all the correct ingredients. My only quibble were the rather dark bacon bits, but the poached egg was a thing of beauty and the portion large. I’d heard that Scot insisted on keeping his fish pie (named “classic fish pie”) on the menu so I ordered it, though I was sorely tempted by the 100% rib eye burger. The pie came with its own generous side salad and it was a cloud of light but crusted potato covering the creamy, fresh fish and prawns. The flavours were mild, but pure.

Service was outstanding, courteous and on the button – with one glitch. On arrival I visited the gents to find the soap pretty spent. Informed my waiter, then at the end of the meal thought I’d check, not replenished.

Wine list is mainly estate own, also by the carafe, but this is supplemented by a small list of other wines. Overall, the prices strike one as being on the high side, but portions are generous, so value is fair. Starters (often enough for a light meal) sit at R50-R88; mains R85-R125. I finished (or rather was finished) by the pecan nut tart, with home-made vanilla ice cream – it was excellent and again big.

So certainly worth a turn, or to put back on your visit list. Coffee also been much improved, so that’s also an option.

Daily breakfast and lunch. Constantia Uitsig Farm,Spaanschemat River Road. 021 794 3010

Posted in Posts, Restaurants Cape | 2 Comments

Great sushi in Cape Town and Durban

By JPR | Published: January 28, 2010

Cape Town

Nobu, One&Only, V&A Waterfront. 021 431 5111. Dinner nightly. Price: Expensive.

Nobuyuki Matsuhisa now has 22 restaurants around the world, making his famous “Nobu” line one of the most upmarket chains on the planet. Relative ubiquity notwithstanding, the arrival of the first African Nobu irrevocably changed the South African sushi landscape – this is the place to experience it at its best. Whether you order à la carte or choose a set menu like the omakase (“from the heart”) chef’s selection, the fish is of the highest grade and the presentation true to the precise aesthetic of Japanese culture – every plate beautiful (no coloured plastic here). A South African omakase menu features only local seafoods, while the other menus showcase local and global delicacies. But most importantly, Hideki Maeda, head chef, is a master of the sushi-meshi, the rice – the discernibly individual, firm-to-the-bite grains held together by a delicate magnetism, never bluntly compressed, a mark of the finest. Wines: Sake is the preferred drink, and the choice is intriguing, from the dry Hokusetsu “devil killer” to the “aged music book” – or choose wine from a carefully selected list gleaned from the hotel’s immense cellar. You can of course ask for the maze sommelier to bring his biblical list over.

… continue reading

Posted in Food talk | 2 Comments

Hermanos, Hermanus

By JPR | Published: January 25, 2010

One of the basic rules of keeping a restaurant is keeping your locals happy. On the coast, and in city hotspots, there is plenty of temptation to cater to the du jour masses who’re here now, but when they’re gone, it’s your local and you. The brothers behind Hermanos, a relatively new spot in Hermanus, seem to get it. They’ve created a place that looks relatively upmarket, but in fact serves very reassuring food, the kind that the Hermanus local, a generally conservative eater, prefers. They aren’t aiming too high, and they’re pretty much on target.

Hermanos is set in a lovely house with an irresistible courtyard with decorative fireplace, the interior is light toned on warm tiles, walls adorned by simple “Picasso style” line drawings on natural paper. White clothed tables and sunflowers, the waiters all in neat uniform. The standout on this visit was the professional manner of the service staff: in the delivery of menu and the execution of duties all very good. Overall, the restaurant has a very elegant feeling, calming. The wine list is mainly local and well priced, while the menu is tight: five starters and seven main courses, four desserts. The choices err on the simple side, and for a place of these lines, their signature turns out to be… ribeye steak with rosemary wedges.

Starters include – tiger prawn and avocado stack; Thai fish koftas; risotto of asparagus and parma. Mains like – beef fillet served on hot rock; rack of lamb with polenta; fillet of pork with sage butter, horseradish mash and cranberry sauce; crespelle of vegetables; creme brulee, Signature chocolate tart. Prices are very reasonable at around R40 for starters and R70-100 for mains – another canny move.

So, a lovely space and excellent service. It’s all up to the food… which is ordinary – generally safe, but verging to being off the mark. Perhaps it was best to order a hot rock fillet or a ribeye steak, since our choices were not memorable, leaving us feeling fed, but not necessarily nourished. The risotto was passable but over-cooked (probably cooked to the SA palate?), the fish koftas good but served with sweet chili sauce that could have come from a bottle. The vegetable crespelle was not such, more a moist veg bake, underseasoned. Pork fillet was perfectly cooked and tender, but also lacking in seasoning (no discernible sage) and the “horseradish” mash was neutral. Even the cranberry was mute. To finish, the chocolate tart, promised by the waiter to be for serious chocolate lovers only, being so dark, was mild and fatty, served with vanilla ice cream that only accentuated its fattiness. Coffee poor.

All in all, its a neighbourhood regular, dressed up. Which could actually be a very good concept, just the menu needs to be careful not to over-extend, which some courses seem to. I’ll try the steak next time – the hot rocks were sizzling out the kitchen all night.

028 313 1916.

Posted in Restaurants Cape | Leave a comment

Between the Buns – Searching for a great burger

By JPR | Published: January 22, 2010

You’ve got to love the Americans. Sure they gave us canned laughter, actor-politicians and atomic bombs but they also gave us the Model T, blue jeans – and hamburgers. The burger makes up for a lot of grief. Forget sliced bread, this is the 20th century’s greatest food invention. Other foods come in and out of fashion, but the burger has reigned supreme for over a century and shows no sign of stopping. It’s easily a contender for the most consumed meal in history, the whole globe’s comfort food.

America in your hand, the burger is democracy in food form. “Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses, and I will give them a hamburger.” And just as the American way swept across the globe, so did the burger. Its part and parcel of the States’ cultural colonisation, those double arches striding continents without the need for any shock or awe. Even in the current bearish environment, Macdonald’s is planning to open 1000 stores in 2010. And so it will be recorded that the world was conquered by minced meat, soft white bread, fries, and the soundtrack of mastication.

The result is that many of you hate the burger. … continue reading

Posted in Food talk | 9 Comments

L’Aperitivo, Cape Town

By JPR | Published: January 21, 2010

South African restaurants tend to fall into two broad categories – the self-consciously “special” place (even if the food is plain, it believes it’s special) and the franchise for dining at moderate prices. There are very few true neighbourhood restaurants where eating goes hand in hand with some conversation or a glass of wine; and the meal could be long or short, casual or more formal. Less structured, in other words, where the waiters don’t push you along the drinks-starters-mains-etc track with a relentless eye on the bill. The popularity of SA Italian and Portuguese restaurants is, I think, a function of the fact that people like the less mannered places.

This preamble introduces L’Aperitivo, a new place that certainly falls into the elegant-casual, come-anytime style of European eateries. It’s set on a city corner with lots of passing parade, alongside an art gallery and below a nightclub. Not a big place: bold block colours on the walls, screeded floors, dark brown bistro tables, a prominent bar counter. Streetside tables certainly add to the European feel, and as it happens the owners are Swiss and Italian with clear experience in operating a restaurant, plus they’re on hand and running the show.

The wines are listed on a blackboard, a good selection and most by the glass, good beers too. Similarly, the blackboard menu offers the choices – notable for having no pastas on the day I was there. Instead you can make up a sandwich, or have a caprese (good); seared tuna with roast veg (ok, though the cut of tuna too thin to make seared sing); veal saltimbocca (robust flavours, veal touch dry); or chicken parmigiana; fritatta; etc. Fresh pastries daily, and the almond tart we tried was very good, as were the coffees.

Other notable features are their good cocktails and the cocktail hour from 5-7pm when snacks are served. Prices range from R55 for a salad or snack to R85-95 for a main, so mid-range, but with hearty flavours and very good service this spot is a great addition to the inner city. (Wi-fi also available).

70 Loop Str. Mon to Sat 9 to late. 021 426 1001

Posted in Restaurants Cape | 1 Comment

The Sidewalk Café, Vredehoek

By JPR | Published: January 19, 2010

On a busy corner of a residential suburb, this café is well positioned to be a neighbourhood regular – and happily it delivers. It’s a tiny space (and noisy), the tables are cheek-by-jowl, the space eclectic – it reminded me of a gardener’s cottage mixed with a country kitchen. Think bric-a-brac and mix-matched furniture, domestic objects hanging – successful in its “considered casual” ambience. There are also a few sidewalk tables, and counter seating with a superb view over the bay and Signal Hill. For portable professionals, wi-fi.

The cramped kitchen has been overhauled since this place last traded as a restaurant, thankfully, and now a small paper menu is the result, with casual comfort food where the emphasis is on bold flavour. Standards like Patagonian calamari, chilli and garlic but with a twist of rosemary; mussels in wine; chicken caesar; springbok shank; pastas – but also ideas like a nectarine, nut and feta salad with rocket and Spanish onion; a chicken, prawn, pea and chilli risotto; and asparagus and ricotta ravioli with anchovy cream, pinenuts, parmesan.

Value is excellent, with very few dishes over R100 and most between 40 and 75; breakfast also served, with a “Really Cheap Breakfast” at R20. Then there are sandwiches for between times or whenever people eat sandwiches post school days. And there’s a chicken burger or fish and chips at R65.

Tried a variety of the dishes, calamari was very good, the juices most moppable (the bread good). Linefish was well prepared, risotto (as above) was also well cooked, just crunchy, the chilli was a little exuberant, but ok if you’re ok with it. Ravioli of ricotta and asparagus was on the bland side, the anchovy bite missing, it could have saved the day. Desserts were a mixed bag, a bread and butter pudding was good, in itself, but too dry; while the chocolate brownie was poor – lacking in dark density and oily. Coffee was good. Wine list ordinary and tiny but the wine selection drinkable, prices fair.

In sum: I’d be very happy if this were my regular, and it certainly whips the others in the street. It’s worth a drive too.

33 Derry Street. 021 461 2839. I think it’s open every day, but let me know. Get’s busy, so book.

Posted in Restaurants Cape | Leave a comment

Camil’s, Green Point

By JPR | Published: January 15, 2010

The single-word description for Camil’s, the new restaurant brought to you by the Bouillabaisse team, is eclectic. To this you could add “fun”. It’s in the space that briefly was Geisha, after it moved from Mouille Point, and one hopes this spot will now stay, because we certainly need some playfulness and experimentation in the South African restaurant universe. Not that the food here is experimental in a “too cheffy” way – rather it is unusual through fresh combinations and a choice of dishes that is refreshingly different to the everyday “pasta-steak-salad” menu.

It’s also quite a place to ingest on one visit, there’s so much going on. Firstly, it’s two restaurants in one – the more formal one on the left and a more casual “creperie” on the right. Both are attractive and vibrantly colourful, plus there are lovely courtyard seats. The sections merge into one another and ordering across menus is no problem – and there’s a bewildering selection of menus. Two wine lists, a cocktail list with tapas (replicated on the wall whiteboards), a lunch menu, a bar menu and a dinner menu. You can eat the food in small, medium or large portions. You need to be alert.

Camil and Ingrid Haas are of course well known for their seafood-oriented dishes with an Asian twist, and Camil’s still showcases this category, with a page dedicated, for example, to ways with oyster. You can also try an oysters’ compendium, like “three ways” (incongruously called “Three Musketeers”) which is with three dressings. Alongside there’s a good (though small) selection of champagne, adding yet another arrow to the quiver: the champagne and oyster bar.

The food here is a flurry of creative flavours and ideas. Here are some excerpts: … continue reading

Posted in Restaurants Cape | Leave a comment

Klipkantien, Kalk Bay

By JPR | Published: January 13, 2010

A place that features and supports live music is always to be supported, in my view. There are so few venues left for musicians to play in, especially venues that are conducive to listening. And, being a jazz fan, a venue like Klipkantien that showcases young jazzers is even more of a gem.

Such a pity then that the food is so ordinary. If it’s edible, it’s only because the music is so distracting. Again such a shame, because the young European guys who own the spot are really full of hospitality, and the space is attractive: inside a big wooden bar counter and bistro tables, outside a lovely enclosed courtyard. It’s all part of the Majestic Village, one of Kalk Bay’s inner city re-developments and sits pleasantly just off the main drag. They offer breakfast, lunch and dinner, with music most nights. But you can also just come for the tunes, and have a drink or two.

021 788 2848. www.klipkantien.co.za

Posted in Restaurants Cape | Leave a comment

  • Fairbairn

  • submit your reviews

  • Windfall

  • Recent Comments

  • order the 2010 guide

  • Some latest tweets...

    • Kuzina in new Cape Quarter: as Greek as Brad Pitt in Troy 2 days ago
    • And happy to report that Genki in Stellenbosch makes great food. Fresh, very good rice, lovely presentation. Full review soon. 3 days ago
    • Lunch at Stellenbosch's Genki, cool little sushi joint on the piazza. The usual handrolls and platters, plus they also do Jap tapas &?bento 3 days ago
    • L'Aperitivo at 70 Loop st in Cape Town a great spot ito approach: young Italians doing continental in SA. Food robust, decent. 3 weeks ago
    • Bread at Woodstock's "boutique mall" the Bromwell: tasty burger, chicken; eager but off-target service. Noisy. Swift return unlikely. 3 weeks ago
    • More updates...

    Powered by Twitter Tools

  • subscribe to my feed

Afrigator